This site is sponsored by Rosenfeld Injury Lawyers Call us toll-free to discuss your case: (888) 424-5757

$1,550,000 For a boy in New York who has limited use of one side of his body

Case: Devito v. Opatich, 627 N.Y.S.2d 441 (N.Y. App. Div. 2d Dept. 1995).

Plaintiff (Appellee) - Sabrina Devito
Defendant (Appellant) - J.M. Opatich

Court: New York Appellate Court, 2nd Division (1995)

Procedural History

Parents of an infant who suffered from cerebral palsy on the right side of his body brought a medical malpractice action against the delivering physician.  The Supreme Court, Suffolk County entered a judgment on the jury verdict which awarded the parents $1,550,000, including $50,000 for loss of child's services and loss of society. The Defendant appealed.

Summary of Facts

The parents of an infant who suffered from cerebral palsy on the right side of her body brought an action against the doctor who delivered the infant. The parents were able to show that the infant’s cerebral palsy was caused by the doctor’s negligence.

Outcome at Trial

The jury found the doctor liable for medical negligence, awarding the parents of the infant $1,550,000.

Issues on Appeal

The Defendant contended that the trial court erred by including as an element of the parents' damage, the loss of their minor daughter's society, which is not compensable.

Appellate Court Holdings

The Supreme Court, Appellate Division, held that finding that the infant's cerebral palsy was caused by negligence of the defendant-physician was supported by evidence. However, the Plaintiffs could not recover for loss of their child's society in an action following injury to the child. Finally, the court found that the jury award for loss of the child's services to society was improper because there was no evidence of value of lost services.

Secure Your Child's Future

Put Our Team To Work For You Today!

All consultations are free

About the injured person:

SpastictySeizuresRespiratory difficultiesFacial DeformatiesLearning DisabilitiesBrain InjuryVision ProblemsBone deformatiesOther
All information submitted through this site is confidential.